Is It Worth It

Cole Wehrle has earned a rare kind of designer trust. If his name is on the box, a certain tier of board gamer will buy it without reading the rules. Root, Oath, Pax Pamir 2nd Edition - the man has a track record. Arcs arrived in 2024 trailing that reputation like a comet tail. It sold out fast. It generated immediate debate. And now, two years in, it has settled into something more complicated than pure acclaim: a game that inspires real devotion from some players and genuine frustration from others. ...

Brass: Birmingham has occupied the top spot on BoardGameGeek for years. Not one of the top ten - the top spot. That kind of sustained dominance is almost without precedent in board gaming, and it creates a specific problem: a mountain of hype that either pulls you in or makes you suspicious. So let’s cut through it. Is Brass: Birmingham actually worth buying? Or is it a game that suits a very specific kind of player that might not be you? ...

Pandemic is one of those gateway games that never quite leaves the collection. It’s the cooperative game that made cooperative games respectable - a tight, elegant puzzle about stopping viral outbreaks before the world collapses. With a BGG rating of 7.51 across nearly 136,000 ratings and a permanent spot at #174 overall, it remains one of the most-played games on the planet. But Z-Man Games has been busy. Over the years, Pandemic has accumulated six major expansions plus a growing family of standalone spin-offs with the Pandemic brand on the box. Which ones actually improve the game? Which feel like cash grabs? And which should you buy first? ...

BGG Rank: #38 | Rating: 7.99 | Weight: 2.48/5 | Players: 1-5 | Time: 40-70 min | Age: 10+ Wingspan has a peculiar reputation. It sits at #38 on BGG with nearly 115,000 ratings. It won the Kennerspiel des Jahres in 2019. It’s probably the most-gifted hobby board game of the last decade. And it also generates a specific brand of irritated pushback from experienced gamers who find it shallow, lucky, and overhyped. ...

BGG Rank #6 · Rating 8.41 · Weight 3.08 · 1-4 Players · ~120 min Dune: Imperium is one of those games that earns its position. A top-ten BGG rank is usually something to treat with suspicion - hype, recency bias, and community groupthink all distort the list. This one, though, actually deserves the spot. The question isn’t whether Dune: Imperium is good. It is. The question - especially in 2026 with a standalone sequel and an expansion in the mix - is which version you should buy, and whether any of it is right for you. ...

The Gloomhaven universe sits at the very top of the modern board game canon. Gloomhaven has held a spot in BGG’s top 5 for years. Its successor Frosthaven became the most-funded board game in Kickstarter history at the time of its campaign. And yet somehow Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion - the smaller sibling - is often the smarter buy. Which one should you actually get? That depends entirely on who you are, who you’re playing with, and how much dungeon-crawling chaos you can actually commit to. ...

Terraforming Mars has been a staple of modern board gaming since 2016, and with good reason - few games nail that slow-build engine satisfaction quite like watching your card combos snowball across generations. But with six expansions now available, the buy-in can feel overwhelming. Which ones transform the experience, and which ones are dead weight? We’ve ranked them all, from essential to skippable. The Base Game at a Glance Before diving into expansions, here’s where Terraforming Mars stands: ...

Ark Nova doesn’t need an introduction. It’s the #2 game on BoardGameGeek, sitting at an 8.54 rating with over 88,000 owners. If you’re reading a board game blog, you’ve either played it, want to play it, or are actively avoiding it because the word “zoo” appeared in the same sentence as “3.80 weight.” So when designer Mathias Wigge released Ark Nova: Marine Worlds in 2023, the question wasn’t will people buy it - it was should they? ...